Say it’s Thanksgiving. You’re meeting your new boyfriend’s parents for the first time and want to make a good impression.
Because first impressions are important, right?
So, after throwing all your clothes on the floor, trying on twenty different pairs of shoes, eating a slice of cake, doing jean-lunges across your living room, shopping online for new jeans and calling your mother, what do you do?
You make butternut squash butter, that’s what you do.
And then, just as you are licking the last sweet and spicy bit off your finger and wiping the last crumb of scone off your top lip, you decide this butternut butter would make a real fine housewarming gift!
And then you make more. And tie a cute orange ribbon on the top, tucking it neatly into your checked luggage underneath your new jeans, cute shoes and favorite black dress.
You’ve got this made.
This butternut butter is sweet, rich and spicy (not to mention vegan!) and is absolutely delicious on toast, scones, muffins or swirled into a hot bowl of oatmeal on a chilly morning.
Oh, and it takes only about half an hour to make!
You can totally do this.
First of all, you’ll need some roasted squash. Follow my instructions here.
When cool, peel away the skins and toss in a blender/Vita-Mix/food processor with a half cup of brown sugar, two teaspoons of pumpkin pie spice, one teaspoon vanilla, a pinch of salt and the juice of one lemon.
When it’s all smooth, dump in a pot and simmer for about twenty minutes…or until super thick and creamy.
When it’s done, you can store the butternut butter in a clean, sterilized jar or in tupperware in the fridge, where it will keep for about two weeks.
Spiced Butternut Butter
Makes about two cups
1 butternut squash (about 3 lbs), cut into rounds and roasted at 400 until very tender
1/2 cup brown sugar
2 tsp pumpkin pie spice
pinch salt
1 tsp vanilla
juice of one lemon
Combine all ingredients in a blender or Vita-Mix. Puree until smooth. Transfer to saucepot and cook on medium/low heat for twenty minutes, until thick and smooth. Let cool and store in a clean sterilized jar or in tupperware, where it will keep for about two weeks.
Try it on a cinnamon toast muffin!











{ 84 comments… read them below or add one }
Are those figs? Where are you still finding figs? I haven’t seem them for a month. : ( Do you think this recipe would work with any squash?
And I love your cute bird fabric!
Yep–try acorn! That’d be really yummy. And, yes! California figs and they’re huge! I found ‘em at Whole Foods.
Oh dear, that looks 10X better than apple butter! What if we don’t have a blender handy? If I use some elbow grease I suppose I can do this by hand…???
you could do it by hand!!! Just put the squash in a plastic bag and mash with your fist a meat mallet!
Brenna – You might try a potato masher; the texture will be a bit coarser, but it will get the job done.
What a pretty gift idea. I think that would make a great pitch in or even Christmas present. Nice.
Wonderfully different! Thanks for the fun and fall-flavored recipe, Jenna!!
Woah that looks AMAZING!!!! I want to make that for Christmas gifts for my family this year!
Oooh, I reallllly love that little plate…I also love that you have doily’s
when did your blog get so funny? you didnt use to be funny. no offense!
usually when I try to be funny, it comes of in a really odd and awkward manner and no one laughs. Hopefully this means I’m making progress!
You are definitely succeeding in making it light and humerous.
Yeah – you actually had me wondering “What do you do?!” after the jeans talk LOL – I had to hit the ‘read more’ button
As I was reading this post, I was thinking the same thing…could you be any more amusing (and adorable) lately?!
Great recipe/idea!
yayy…. Its fine to be awkward
Great idea – only had pumpkin butter before!
oh my this looks super!! so thick!!! i bet its would be good on pancakes too!
That looks super yummy. I’m still laughing about your jean lunges…I thought I was the only one who did those….stupid dryer!
jean lunges for life! Every girl does them (i think?)!
i did these yesterday. they didn’t help the situation.
pretty sure i do jean lunges every time i put on my jeans…
It isn’t a complete morning unless I do jean lunges. Sometimes, after a McFlurry or two I just save myself the trouble though and head right to the leggings
I usually do jean squats, they work really well too!
I’ve never tried butternut spread before – would definitely like to give it a go!
Oh my – this is genius. Thank you for sharing the recipe!!
this sounds so yummy… thanks for sharing !
sounds awesome, i’ve never even heard of this!
Is that bird fabric from a craft store? It’s too adorable!
it’s from Beverly’s Fabrics & Crafts!
Oh my gosh woman! I LOVE this!
I have pumpkin butter on the horizon
I never thought to make it with butternut squash though. Any idea if it can be safely canned??
What a great idea! Thanks for the inspiration!
Wow, it never occurred to me to make a butter out of anything other than apples or pumpkins. I am definitely giving this a try!
This isn’t a comment to say “this looks soo good..”
This is a comment to say I am getting off my computer, going out to my porch, grabbing one of my recently harvested squashes, and turning it into this butter. Or bust.
The end.
Cathy B. @ brightbakes
or bust!! wahoooo!
hey i totally made this yesterday afternoon…….and I’m posting about it soon. It was that simple and thaaaaaaaaaaat good!
thanks a bunch!
Cathy B. @ brightbakes
WOW! That looks so luscious
Never thought a butter of sorts could be so pretty in a picture.
Had to lol @ jean lunges! You crack me UP. I do jean squats
This = genious!
It looks so smooth
I hope TSA doesn’t steal your butter.
TSA stole my raspberry preserves from Paris one time and I cried.
End of story.
um, major yum…and spread on a doily, amazing….
This is a perfect housewarming or hostess gift. I’m filing this one away. I’d be proud to give this as a gift….with a little note attached and your blog link for credit.
Well, that looks delicious…especially since I have yet to eat breakfast!
You’re amazing.
I must try this!! I make sweet potato, pumpkin, & apple butter all the time. I will have to go pick up a squash today for sure!
How funny…I have my own butternut butter cooking away in the crock pot right now! Great minds think alike
How cute! I love the presentation too:) Thanks for the great idea – as always.
I’m totally making the Bohemian Wedding Cake recipe for my mom’s birthday this weekend. I’m so excited!
That looks absolutely delicious! Do you think the recipe would work with pumpkin (the real stuff, not canned) rather than butternut squash? Unfortunately butternut squash is not available in Mumbai.
absolutely! Just roast the pumpkin slices, scoop out the flesh and puree with the sugar and spices.
It works really great with with pumpkin. You can add a clove and a cinammon stick or two for additional flavor. Tastes yum.
Fabulous, thanks! Going to give it a go tomorrow, am sure it will taste awesome on oatmeal pancakes.
I never thought of making butternut butter! I just picked up some squash from the farmer’s market yesterday…this might be just the thing to make with it!
I’ve noticed your recipes of late all seem to have pumpkin pie spice & I was just wondering if you buy it or if you make your own. I just did a post about it since its SO stupidly expensive to buy it premade! Just wondering.
Oh & I do jean squats too. Honestly I thought it was just me.
well it’s because I’m out of ground cloves! I bought a small jar of pumpkin pie spice for only $2 at the grocery store the other day…look for McCormick brand!
Mine was $5! I think they jacked the price for the baking season-not cool! Thanks!!
oh i love this idea vs. the usual pumpkin!
That looks really good – do you think cane sugar could work in place of brown sugar?
it would…..but it wouldn’t be the same. Brown sugar gives it that deep rich, almost caramel-like taste. I would honestly go pick up a small box!
Are you anticipating this scenario for your Thanksgiving?
I like how you prepare!
Ahh I want to try this! One more fantastic way to use my Vita-mix!! Plus, I love b-nut squash, so I feel like this is a recipe I HAVE to try!
This sounds delicious! yum!
YUM! I just made pumpkin butter the other day and this looks incredible. I love winter squashes and their versatility!
I love your line about doing jean lunges across the living room. Very funny visual!
This looks fantastic. Who would have thought to make butternut squash butter? Yum.
How do you sterilize the jar?
How lovely and delicious. Now I know what I’m doing this Saturday – roasting squash and making this recipe!
This thoughtful gift will be the icing on the cake.
I think you already have it in the bag with the boyfriend’s parents
Such a great gift! So thoughtful.
What a great hostess gift idea…I love the bird fabric too!
My jaw dropped when I saw this recipe. This is a GENIUS idea!
OMG~ Jenna you just posted a little taste of HEAVEN!!! I just made this butternut butter and I am obsessed! SOOOOOO GOOOOOD! Thank You so much for sharing this!
how much butternut squash to this amount of sugar? i just harvested two wheelbarrows of butternut squash and i’ve made chili, stew, various pasta dishes, a moroccan couscous dish, black bean and bnut burritos, a casserole, i’m making gnocchi this weekend, and i guess i better put up some bnut butter, before i turn into one myself.
sorry,I should have clarified that! You’ll need about a three pound squash for 1/2 cup sugar.
Awesome idea! I just made homemade pumpkin butter, so when I finish THAT up, I’ll move on to butternut squash
Ooo- what a fun recipe! I love apple butter and pumpkin butter so I HAVE to try this =)
BEST holiday gift ever!! Thank you so much for the awesome idea!!
p.s. secretly obsessed with you for admitting to the jean-lunges.
Ooh, Jenna! This looks delicious – the next logical step after pumpkin butter and apple butter.
Question: What are jean lunges? lol, but seriously, i’ve never heard of them.
I MUST try this!
That looks fantastic! What a great idea for a gift, love it!
Just made this last night as I had a beautiful little bell shaped squash staring at me from my fruit basket. It tastes great on toast but I think I snacked too much on my squash because it turned out a bit too lemony. I’ve learned my lesson: never make Butternut Butter hungry. For shame!
Thanks so much for this! I made it tonight with a bnut squash from my garden and it’s amazing <3 I think I might take about half of it and bake it into some muffins!
Damn, this looks so thick and tasty! YUM!
Hey, this looks great and I want to make some for christmas gifts. Do you think you could can it? I am extremely new to canning (as in learned how to yesterday) and I don’t want to inadvertently poison my grandmother!
absolutely! Just be sure to read canning techniques on how to properly boil and prepare the cans (the Gourmet cookbook has a great instructional page for that).
Was poking around your website for a bread to make for the boyfriend’s fam when I meet them for the first time this week. Found the Cinnamon Walnut Bread, which led me here — clearly I came to the right place to this exact occasion.
{ 1 trackback }