This is for all you cheese lovers out there.
Last summer, I posted a recipe for dairy-free stuffed shells. They’re good. But they’re dairy-free. I eat them when I feel like being dairy-free. I make them for vegan friends and after weekends that involve hot dogs, french fries and grilled steak. In my mind, there’s time and place for everything including nutritional yeast, blocks of velveeta, green juice and dr. pepper. It’s all about moderation, right?
These shells do not contain tofu nor nutritional yeast…and they are best eaten alongside some buttery garlic bread and a big glass of red wine.
I actually posted this recipe back in 2009. I just love it so much! And when was trying to think of a meal to bring to a friend who just had a baby girl last week, I dusted it back off. I actually wasn’t going to re-post it, but then I thought maybe some new readers might have missed the original. And I just couldn’t stand the thought of that. It would simply be a tragedy to miss out on something this good.
Plus, the original recipe was without photos and in all italics because I used to think it was cool back in 2009 to write recipes in all italics. If Comic Sans was an option for font I probably would have used that, too. Just saying….sometimes recipes are worth a re-post.
The cheesy filling is a blend of ricotta cheese, Italian blend cheeses, Parmesan cheese, cottage cheese and spinach. It’s absolutely comfort food at its very best. I used to make these stuffed shells all the time while I was in culinary school and living in Orlando with my friend, Helen. I’d make big batches on Sunday night and we’d eat it all.week.long since neither of us had any time to cook during the week (ironic that I had no time to cook during culinary school). Sometimes I added a bit of spicy chicken sausage to the sauce, but often just left them vegetarian.
So, make a big batch this weekend! Spinach makes them healthy, right?
Cheesy Spinach Stuffed Shells
serves 6
Ingredients:
12 oz box jumbo shells
1 15-oz container ricotta cheese
1 cup Italian blend grated cheese
3/4 cup grated Parmesan cheese
12 oz cottage cheese
1 tsp salt
1/4 tsp pepper
dash of ground nutmeg
24 oz of your favorite marinara sauce
1 1/2 cups grated mozzerella cheese
10 oz frozen spinach, defrosted with liquid wrung out
Directions:
Preheat oven to 375 degrees.
Boil the pasta in salted water. Drain and lay out shells on a wax paper lined kitchen counter. Let cool and make the filling.
In a large bowl, combine the ricotta, cottage cheese, Italian cheese blend, Parmesan, salt, pepper, nutmeg and spinach. Mix well.
Spoon about tbsp of cheese into each shell and lay each seam side up into a greased 9 x 12″ casserole dish. You will have a little extra—I usually bake those in a smaller dish alongside the big dish. Pour the sauce over the shells and sprinkle on the mozzarella cheese.
Cover with tin foil and bake 30 minutes. Enjoy!
Time:
1 hour






{ 57 comments… read them below or add one }
These look super duper yummy. I haven’t tried stuffed shells before, I normally stick to lasagna but you might have just convinced me otherwise. Wine and garlic bread is a must….and good friends.
My Husband loves when I make stuffed shells and I love it because there are always yummy leftovers. I pretty much make them the same way you do except the cottage cheese. I don’t use that. I will be trying the spinach next time though to get some extra veggies in for the kid.
Yum! I completely agree … all Italian food must be consumed with a nice glass of wine!
Oh comic sans!! I had a professor who ALWAYS used that font.
I’m plotting the perfect time to make this recipe and freeze it when I will desperately need it.
LOL about the Comic Sans thing. I noticed yesterday that it was actually a trending topic on Twitter! I’ll admit I used to think it was pretty great back in the day too, and now can’t stand it. Spinach stuffed into pasta however, now that, I love. Great photos!
Ooooooooh these look so good. I like the idea you mentioned to add a bit of chicken sausage to the sauce, though I’m sure these are delicious without it!
Mmmm I have to admitt i am obsessed with the dairy free shells, so i have no doubt these will be amazing
These look incredible! I love the vegan version, but being from Wisconsin I can’t go cheese-less for too long. Thanks for the re-post
These look fantastic, but I’m really glad you linked to the dairy-free ones! I had to give up most dairy because it makes my skin break out
I miss cheese.
Mmm…definitely worth the re-post Jenna. And I love that you managed to throw in Velveeta cheese. LOL. My Dad and I used to love gobbling this stuff up (much to my mother’s chagrin) – aaah, such fond memories ; )
Ha! Oh my goodness…I used to write EVERYTHING in Comic Sans!!!
These look delicious! I definitely have options for my vegan and gluten-free friends, but so love the originals too. Yum!
Oh man is it weird that I actually remember you posting the original recipe back in’09? Haha I feel like I have to meet you one of these days after reading about your life for sooo darn long on the blog. Either way, these looks yummy!
what brand of sauce did you use? when it’s not homemade i have the hardest time finding a good marinara. this looks delish.
stuffed shells are one of my all time favorites! Thanks for re-posting this!!
Stuffed shells are so worth the mess of filling them. Cheesy, tomato-y love
I like the simple ingredient list! Easy, simple and yet looks wonderful
I make something similar but with pesto instead of spinach – so good!
Woah! This look fabulous!
Hi Jenna!
The recipe looks good but….if you wanted to substitute the cottage cheese what would you use.
I recommend keeping the cottage cheese in there and not modifying, but I’m guessing you could try using more ricotta in place of it (I haven’t tried this so I can’t guarantee it will work).
Stuffed shells are on my “to-make” list. I am definitely printing out this recipe!
Oh man. I know you have the vegan recipe, and I should make them for my dairy allergic husband, but I WANT THESE. Oh riccota, I miss you so. I’ve managed to veganize some of my other favorites (like vodka sauce, thank goodness: http://lollingabout.wordpress.com/2012/05/18/foodie-friday-vodka-sauce/) but sometimes… I just want the real deal. Cheese is a beautiful, beautiful thing.
Yum. Love the stuffed shells idea. I need to change up my standard pasta lineup. This looks wonderful
Stuffed shells are always a good idea! Love this recipe, thanks so much for sharing
How did you just make me crave a warm baked pasta dish even though it’s 90 degrees outside? Seriously all I want right now is some cozy and comforting stuffed shells!
You were not kidding about a cheesy recipe coming our way.
This looks like dynamite and absolutely needs to go with a good wine.
Definitely feel you on the “no time to cook while in culinary school”–I felt the exact same way. It is so ironic!
Love how delicious and easy this is! Also love the cheese combination… Yum!
I’m a cheese lover, so I guess this recipe is for me!
Looks super good.
So funny. I had this meal for dinner last night. My filling was definitely lacking in the cheese department. Next time I make it I will up the cheese ante.
I like the suggested pairing of buttery garlic bread and a big glass of red wine. THAT I can get down with. Happy Friday Jenna!
mmm, i’ve been wanting to make stuffed shells soon. but i have to wait another month, because i’m moving. [i like to freeze some when i make them, and i really don't want to have to deal with toting around a dish of frozen stuffed shells on moving day
]
i’ve never done half ricotta and half cottage cheese, but i bet i will LOVE it that way!
CHEESE OVERLOAD AND I LOVE IT.
Seriously, I could die and go to cheese heaven right now.
After having a baby, any! kind of food anyone wants to make and bring would be welcome…especially these!!
Classic pasta dish! Pasta with red sauce and ricotta has always been one of my favorites…even though I’d totally eat your dairy-free version too (sounds delish), this recipe looks awesome!
Can’t go wrong with comfort food, especially comfort food paired with wine!
My brother pretty much lived on Kraft mac and cheese when he was in culinary school. That was all he could muster himself to make once he got home after staring at, like, figs and brie for 12 hours.
This looks absolutely delicious! It seems fairly simple, too. Maybe I’ll try it out!
I actually have made this before based on your original 2009 post. It is a goodie!
I love stuffed shells! So many possibilities and they’re all sooo good.
Your site is one of my favorites! Lovely photos, yummy recipes, excellent commentary. Keep up the good work!
You had me at “For all the cheese lovers…” Pinned!
I’m thrilled you decided to re-post this recipe – I love stuffed shells and can’t remember the last time I had them. I think these are going on the dinner menu for next week
Wow, these look quite tasty! I was looking over old recipes, trying to come up with things to make over the weekend, and this will definitely be one of them!
This recipe looks great! I wanted to pin this on pinterest but on your FAQ you ask that your photos not be used on other sites. Just wondered if this included pinterest if linked back to your blog? I read your blog often and like to save recipes for future use. Thanks!
Pinterest is fine, thanks for asking!
These look so dang delicious! Awesome!
I am definitely one of those cheese-lovers! I love it when I find these recipes– my family will be enjoying Italian food tomorrow night!
Stuffed shells always remind me of my grandma! She was the biggest proponent of ricotta cheese I know of
Mmm… they look delicious! I absolutely love how there are so many different ways to make Stuffed Shells!! Thank you so much for sharing the recipe
Have a great weekend!
Um, I die.
I just made these and they are aaaaaaaaaaaaamazing!! I was skeptical at first about the cottage cheese but man, it was amazing.
I love stuffed shells and haven’t made them in ages. I’ve never made them with cottage cheese but now I’m intrigued. I think they’re going on the list.
Thank you so much for sharing this recipe – absolutely delicious!
Have these ready to pop into the oven, just as soon as I hear from my son, who is visiting; haven’t seen him in two years. Think this is the perfect dish to welcome him. Thanks for sharing it!
I made these last night, after making stop at 3 different grocery stores to look for jumbo shells. Worth it. The nutmeg makes this recipe.
I made these last night and added a lil bit of diced italian sausage and boy it was delish!!!! I posted it and my friends want the recipe, I want to share this! Very tasty and simple dish!!!!
I made this today with my daughter, she is so proud to have done this and they turned out fantastic!
{ 9 trackbacks }