Wow, I am so excited to share this recipe with y’all today!!!
I don’t know about you, but the start of fall makes me crave comforting meals like homemade spaghetti sauce. There’s just something to standing in front of the stove, stirring a HUGE pot of sauce while it simmers for hours that calms me right down. I made this sauce, which is my mother’s recipe and, in my opinion, the best tasting spaghetti sauce in the entire world, a couple weeks ago when my book came out. I included this recipe in the book so I made it to celebrate the launch. After a few bites, Adam claimed it was the best meat sauce he ever tasted. Bold statement, huh? It’s true! Two days later I made another huge batch to take over to Ashley’s house because she is pregnant and has morning sickness so badly that she can’t even stand to open her fridge to cook. Let’s just say that it was a gift very well received by her husband and daughter.
I never included this recipe on my blog before because, well, it was sort of an old family secret, but I think it’s time you guys taste it for yourself.
I grew up eating this sauce. Just the smell of it reminds of home. It’s actually my mother’s ex-boyfriend’s recipe from way back in the day. I’m glad things didn’t work out between them {or else I wouldn’t be here right now!}, but I AM glad they were together long enough for her to grab this amazing sauce recipe. I’m not sure how my dad feels about that, but I do know he loves this spaghetti sauce as well.
Now for the “secrets” that make this sauce so addicting!
1. Simmering the sauce for two hours with lots of cheese in mixed in.
2. Wine and lots of it.
3. Garlic salt and lots of it.
4. A blend of ground beef and hot Italian sausage.
I can’t believe I just shared that! But good—there are no secrets between us anymore. I feel better, don’t you?
Like most sauces, there’s no real “recipe” for this. The recipe in the book is pretty loose because it really is “just a pinch of this and a drizzle of that”. However, last time when I made it for Ashley’s family I wrote down exactly what I did {or tried to, at least}. You still have the ability to alter the sauce to your taste buds and I encourage tasting it throughout the cooking process!
Just remember the golden rule: when in doubt, add more wine!
{that goes for yourself, too. duh}
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
serves 6-8
Ingredients:
1.5 lbs ground beef (or turkey)
1 lb hot Italian sausage
20 oz sliced mushrooms
1 green bell pepper, chopped
1 yellow onion, chopped
1 red bell pepper, chopped
1.5 tbsp olive oil
1 28-oz can tomato puree
1 12-oz can tomato paste
24 oz tomato sauce
BIG splash red wine (whatever “big splash” means to you: anywhere from 1/2 cup to 2 cups will do fine. Heh heh)
6 oz freshly grated Romano cheese
1 tbsp dried oregano
1 tbsp dried basil
1 bay leaf
1-2 tbsp sugar
garlic salt + pepper as needed
spaghetti noodles + additional grated cheese for serving
Directions:
Heat the olive oil in a large pot over medium heat. Once hot, add the onion, bell peppers and sliced mushrooms. Saute for about six – eight minutes, until mushrooms are soft. Add ground beef and sausage meat. Cook until meat browns, stirring frequently with a large rubber spatula.
Add tomato puree, tomato sauce and tomato paste to the pot. Stir well. Then, add the bay leaf, wine, spices, sugar and cheese. Stir well and bring sauce to a simmer.
Simmer sauce for an hour and a half over low heat, stirring occasionally. Taste it as you cook, adding more wine, spices or garlic salt to suite your taste buds. The longer the sauce cooks, the better it will taste!
Serve sauce over hot spaghetti noodles with extra cheese. Sauce can be refrigerated for up to five days or frozen for up to three months. Sauce will taste better the next day, after flavors have time to meld.
Time:
2 hours







{ 77 comments… read them below or add one }
I was laying in bed the other night, reading White Jacket Required, having just made my own sauce earlier that day for he first time, and thought to myself, “darn, I wish I had read one chapter further last night.” And now here it is again! It’s a sign that I need to try it
You’re book is fantastic, and I look forward to reading your blog every morning over coffee and oatmeal. Thank you, Jenna!
Yum! This looks amazing. My husband would die if I made this for him.
P.S. I cannot wait until my copy of your book arrives!
Whoa! Craziness! I posted yesterday about zucchini pasta with a meat sauce! Great minds think alike!!!
Yummm! 2 hours is a long time for simmering but I’m sure it is well worth the wait! Spaghetti was one of my mum’s staple dinners when we were growing up, and it definitely still screams comfort food to me now. Great photos!
I can hear honey badger saying to this former bf, “Thanks for the sauce, stupid.”
This sauce sounds absolutely delicious! I will definitely have to give it a try.
Enjoyed your book immensely and look forward to trying the recipes. I have tried many from your blog and nothing has ever dissapointed. I look forward to reading more from you!
I like that rule. I’ve found myself craving spaghetti and meatballs, just because that’s what I grew up with, but this sounds even better. I’m going to have to be exclusive and tell my vegetarian roommate it’s just tooooo bad because that meaty richness is simply necessary. Thank you so much for sharing!
Nothing like a big plate of spaghetti! This looks delicious!
Mmmmm I love homemade sauce.. I use my mom’s recipe which is so my great grandma’s recipe, and I think IT is the best in the world haha we all have our favorites that remind us of home.
Happy Friday!
I just wanted to say that I finished your book last night and enjoyed every page! You inspired me to get out of my food funk and start cooking/baking again. Thank you for you wonderful blog too! I love the pictures and amazing recipes!
my mouth is watering!!! perfect for autumn too
Happy Friday Jenna! Thanks for sharing your Secret Family Recipe. When secrets involve food…it’s always best to share, don’t you think?! LOL ; )
I’ve been looking for a good spaghetti sauce lately! I hate huge chunks of tomatoes in my sauce, so this one looks perfect. Plus it has wine. Win, win.
Love homemade spaghetti sauce…it’s been a long time since I’ve made it, I’ll have to get back into that habit.
By “sausage meat”, do you really mean to remove the sausage from the casing and to break it up? This direction is not clear.
Yep, that’s exactly what I mean!
This looks heavenly. Seriously, cannot wait to make this.
Thanks for sharing your deepest, sauciest secrets with us
This spaghetti sauce sounds awesome!! It’s very similar to my mom’s recipe, except she uses all ground beef (no Italian sausage), and she doesn’t use any wine – but that sounds like a GREAT addition
Perfect spaghetti & love the mushrooms, too! It’s still not spaghetti weather here (in the 80s and 90sF!) but soon!
Date night for my wife tonight with this recipe! You rock!
Now that’s a stellar husband right there! You rock, too! ;o)
Jenna, I love your sauce secrets shared with us today! I’m glad the secrets are out. Homemade spaghetti sauce reminds me of home.
I have to tell you that these photos are beautiful – crisp and bright. PERFECT. Best photos I’ve seen on ELR. I hope to emulate your photography one day!
Making me want some spaghetti now! I never thought to put wine or cheese in my sauces before, but seeing as how those are two of my favorite things, it sounds like a pretty damn good idea to me!
We make this at least once or twice a month; I’m going to try your recipe next!
Looks great! I did have a question: do you not have to drain any of the fat from the beef? Just leave it all in? Excited to try this!
You don’t drain the fat! That’s why it is so delicious.
Oh wow, it’s barely lunch time and you’ve got me craving a HUGE plate of this! Looks so good.
This looks amazing! Question: Do you use red or white wine or does it matter?
RED!!
Yum… So classic, so good. Will have to make this ASAP!
WOW, this looks amazing! I’m totally making this for football Sunday. Thank you for sharing.
Looks delicious!!! And can’t wait to read your book!!!!
Also, not sure if maybe its just happening to me for some reason but over the last few days every time i try to go to eatliverun.com a blank page pops up and says Welcome to Nginx! The only way I can get to your site now is by going back to one of the old links in my browser i.e eatliverun.com/steak-gorgonzola-and-cherry-tomato-pizza/ and then once im in i can clink the side links to see your new post. is it just me?
I read the book, Melissa and it is so good!
You can’t go wrong with spaghetti! Especially if there is garlic bread involved.
Every time I see “meat sauce” it makes me giggle. I was staying at a hotel in Salt Lake City and their room service menu had Spaghetti with Meat Sauce on it. Then there was a note that said “meat sauce does not contain meat”. What?
I ADORE spaghetti and super love how it just gets better with time. Best leftovers ever. Thank you so much for sharing!
What a delicious recipe Jenna. Meat sauces can really benefit from the addition of mushrooms, they add tons of flavor and nutrients.
Your secret is out, and now I’m totally going to use it! I never simmer the sauce with the cheese in it, but it makes perfect sense.
Oh simple pasta with a divine sauce is just what the soul needs some nights. This look fantastic. Adding it to the meal plan for the week.
Anything with red wine and cheese is a winner in my books. Thank you to you and your mom (and your mom’s ex-boyfriend) for this lovely recipe – I can’t wait to try it!
These types of recipes are always the best ones
Thanks for sharing!
I will be using 2 cups of wine. Love me some boozy sauces, lol. This looks fantastic! And I am definitely downloading your book today. Cannot wait!
I am with you there! As soon as it starts to get cooler, I crave all the comfort foods. I am in the process of lightening up some of my favourite recipes.
Totally making this, but going to attempt to make a vegetarian version with fake ground beef in the red packaging (can’t think of the name) and that soy italian sausage….wish me luck!
will make this tomorrow to get me through the work week! thanks, jenna’s mom!
Jenna, you’re hysterical – “There are no more secrets between us. I feel better.” ! I’m not usually a meat sauce person but this look like it’d be worth a try!
Back in the 1970′s, I had a very similar sauce at a friend’s house. He called this “California Spaghetti.” The only difference was that he added sliced black olives. I’m not a big eater, but I polished off two plates! He was kind enough to give me the recipe and it is an old favorite.
Hi!
The spaghetti looks delish! I love that the recipe calls for lots of wine
Just wanted you to know that I finished your book the other day and I loved reading it. I only started reading your blog (or even knowing what a blog was) a couple of months ago, every single one of your stories was so heartfelt, easy to read, and down-to-earth. You manage to be an expert in the area of cooking and baking and to make those of us who aren’t feel like we could be!
This looks amazing!! Yes, sometimes i feel like a big bowl of pasta would hit the spot in autumn and every other season too:)
This week I made two of your recipes: whole wheat banana peach muffins and this sauce. Actually, the sauce is simmering right now – perfect for a lazy Sunday afternoon. I can’t wait to have spaghetti and meat sauce every day this week.
I love your blog and your recipes! Now I need to get my hands on a copy of your new book.
Hope you had a good weekend!
I highly recommend you getting and sharing another of your moms recipes. My husband and I were the lucky recipients of her culinary talents last night. It was a beef dish with olives served on a bed of rice that was delicious and so tender. She said it was a secret but I’m sure she’d share it with you! (and then you can pass it on your readers) Dessert was a chocolate torte! Can’t wait to meet you when you come to Savannah!!
Hi Jenna! I just wondered if I missed the September edition of your fave things!
Nope! I haven’t posted yet
This looks absolutely amazing I could eat the entire pot!
This reminds me of the sauce my grandma used to make for spaghetti. I always hated green bell peppers growing up but she would put them in that sauce and I just loved it. Tons of chunky ground beef, lots of spices, and loads of flavor. So nostalgic.
You must know, I made this tonight and seriously, oh my gosh. If Heaven had a taste, this would be it. A-Maz-Ing. Best recipe I’ve tried of yours yet. Thank you SO MUCH for sharing this gem.
Now I REALLY want spaghetti
Do you ever use this sauce in lasagna? Or is it too heavy?
You totally could!
I made this over the weekend Jenna! I used fresh basil, which was delicious, and I think I might sub parmesan or bella vitano cheese next time. I love how it made a huge pot that I could divide into two and share with family members. There’s just something about a tupperware container full of meat sauce paired with a pack of linguine that just says I love you! Thanks for the great recipe! -Meg
Made this tonight. It was delicious and a HUGE hit with the hubby! Thanks for sharing. Oh and, FYI, my “big splash” of wine measured out to 1 1/2 cups!.
This sauce looks delicious! I think he is nuts, but my boyfriend hates mushrooms. Can you omit them without loosing much of the flavor? Thanks!
Would love to know what kind of red wine you recommend. I’m a white wine drinker, so know absolutely nothing about buying red wine, but sounds like the perfect addition to the sauce. Can’t wait to make this!
this sounds delicious!! Excited to try it this weekend. Can you tell me how much the recipe makes, and does it freeze well?
Stacey
do you think this would be good for the crockpot??
do the meat and veggies on stove top, then transfer it and the rest of the ingredients to the crockpot?
I want to make this for my work potluck next week..
Hmmm I have not tried that so I can’t say for sure! I THINK it would work though, and be pretty great!
This recipe is very similar to the one I have used for years that my dad passed on to me. I use real garlic and whole tomatoes instead of the sauce. Then instead of olive oil I cook bacon and use the drippings to saute the onions, garlic, peppers and I add chopped celery. After it has simmered for a while I toss in the bacon crumbled up and add more red wine. The sugar is the secret in this recipe. Shhhhh.
It is much better the next day and freezes great. I have even made this and shipped across the country. I have sometimes added little slices of pepperoni before but that is a personal preferrence. Hope everyone here tried it and loves it.
My husband and I made this on Sunday and totally agree–BEST. SAUCE. EVER. It’s so complex tasting! And I love that although it’s a meat sauce, there are still a lot of vegetables. We have two quarts in the freezer and I’m looking forward to spaghetti for lunch all week.
Can you give me a better idea of how much garlic salt and pepper to use. Thanks
This looks amazing! I can’t wait to try it
ok, is there magic in using a “large rubber spatula”? or will any cooking utensil do? lol i’m kinda asking seriously because i’m a total recipe to the T girl
I just have to tell you that I love this pasta sauce! It has become a new family favorite! We will never go back to sauce in a jar, thank you so much for this amazing recipe!
I made this sauce (doubled the recipe) last night for my church small group. Everyone loved it! And I was glad to have leftovers to freeze
Can’t wait to try it…saw it posted on How Sweet It Is
I made this tonight and it was so awesome! Tons of leftovers too. One question: when you simmer it, do you put the lid on or leave it off? Thanks for the recipe!
Made this tonight for the family. HUGE hit! I totally forgot to get the red wine and it was still amazing. Next time I’ll be sure to remember the wine! Thank you!
{ 14 trackbacks }